Decommissioning of the USS Crommelin (FFG-37)

By Elizabeth Crommelin Pennewill,
edited by Katharine Milton-Crommelin


JOINT BASE PEARL HARBOR-HICKAM, Honolulu, Hawaii – The crew and staff of the USS Crommelin (FFG-37) along with Crommelin family members, alumni and guests gathered on 26 October 2012 to say goodbye to the ship after almost 30 years of distinguished Naval service. Crommelin, the 28th of the Oliver Hazard Perry-class of guided-missile frigates, was decommissioned in a moving ceremony under a clear Hawaiian sky.

Crommelin was named after three of the five famous Crommelin brothers from Wetumpka, Alabama, who graduated from the US Naval Academy between 1923 and 1941 and served heroically in World War II: Vice Admiral Henry C. Crommelin (1904-1971), Commander Charles L. Crommelin (1909-1945) and Lieutenant Commander Richard G. Crommelin (1917-1945). The other brothers are Rear Admiral John G. Crommelin, III (1902-1996) and Captain Quentin C. Crommelin (1919-1997). When the youngest, Quentin, graduated in 1941, it marked the first and only time five siblings were ever to graduate from the academy. The Navy Department commented, “The only reason there aren’t any more Crommelin brothers in the Navy is because the Crommelins are out of boys.” They became one of the most decorated families in US Naval history.


Launch and Christening Ceremony, 2 July 1981

In July of 1981, thirty-eight years after the end of WWII and with only two of the brothers still alive, Crommelin was christened and launched at a ceremony at Todd Pacific Shipyard in Seattle. The launching ceremony was sponsored by Mrs. Sally Crommelin-Huntress (widow of the late Henry Crommelin), Mrs. Carol Anne Meyers-Crommelin (daughter of the late Commander and Mrs. Charles L. Crommelin) and Mrs. Susan Costenbader-Crommelin (daughter of the late Lieutenant Commander Richard G. Crommelin and Ann Walkley).


(LtoR: Mrs. Susan Costenbader-Crommelin; Mrs. Henry Crommelin; Mrs. Carol Anne Meyers-Crommelin

Assigned to the Pacific Fleet, Crommelin’s mission was to provide anti-air, anti-submarine and anti-surface protection for underway replenishment groups, convoys, amphibious forces and other military and merchant shipping. Since her launch she has been greeted by Crommelin family members upon arrival at various ports of call all over the world.

The eldest of the famous brothers was John G. Crommelin, III. His grandson, John G. Crommelin, V, was the only direct descendent of the brothers attending the decommissioning ceremony. Other Crommelins who traveled to Pearl Harbor for the occasion were Elizabeth Crommelin Bunce of Oregon along with her brother, two daughters and several grandchildren, and Elizabeth Crommelin Pennewill of South Carolina (descended from John G. Crommelin III’s aunt, Margaretta Crommelin, also of Alabama.)

Arriving at the pier which was lined with flags from all 50 states, I was greeted by a naval officer who gave me the traditional Hawaiian flower lei greeting and showed me to the seats reserved for family members. There I met John G. Crommelin, V, (my third cousin) for the first time. Originally from Atlanta, John now lives on the “Big Island” of Hawaii. He attended the ceremony with his girlfriend, Yumi Nagayoshi. It was an overwhelming experience to be at Pearl Harbor, to see Crommelin for the first (and last) time after hearing about it all my life, and to meet my cousin John.


LtoR: Elizabeth Crommelin Pennewill, John G. Crommelin V, Yumi Nagayoshi

Soon it was time for the ceremony to begin. Guests rose from their seats as the Navy band played the National Anthem and watched as several officers and crew boarded the ship to man the rails for the official decommissioning ceremony.


The Navy Band plays the National Anthem

The arrival of the official party marked the beginning of a full immersion into a grand naval tradition. As each member of the official party emerged from between two lines of saluting sailors, a Petty Officer rang two bells and the name of the official was called out by the ceremony’s emcee. “Captain J. W. Orvis, United States Navy, Retired, Arriving.”


LtCdr Jeff Smith, Emcee of the Decommissioning Ceremony

Following the traditional parading of the colors and the Invocation given by Crommelin’s Chaplain, Lieutenant Commander Jeff Smith spoke about the Crommelin brothers, describing their gallantry and heroism in WWII. Four of the brothers became naval aviators, while Henry, due to poor eyesight became a “brown shoe” and made his mark aboard destroyers. Guests were told that before the war's end, at least one brother had seen action in every major naval engagement in the Pacific. LtCdr Smith also described the Jan. 24, 1944 edition of Time Magazine which dubbed the five brothers “The Indestructibles”, a moniker that eventually became the ship’s mantra. Individually and as a fighting family, the brothers attained outstanding combat records and multiple decorations. Several books have been written about them; other books have been dedicated to them and monuments commemorating their bravery rest in several sites in Alabama.


Guest speaker, Capt. J.W. Orvis (Ret.), Crommelin's first Commanding Officer

Next, Crommelin’s current Commanding Officer (CO), Commander Michael D. Johns, gave his remarks and introduced the guest speaker who was Crommelin’s first CO assigned in 1983, Captain J.W. Orvis (Ret). He spoke proudly about Crommelin's long and distinguished service.


The 'Crew March-off' marks the beginning of the Decommissioning Ceremony

Then the traditional crew march-off was ordered by CDR Johns and the crew and officers who had been manning rails slowly marched one by one down the gangway. On the pier they formed several rows and stood at attention before the guests. A small number of crew members remained aboard ship for the most moving portion of the ceremony which followed. It began with the CO who was standing on the pier. First he ordered "Strike eight bells," signifying the termination of the final watch, and the bell rang out eight times.


Lowering of the National Ensign, 26 October 2012

He then called out to the Executive Officer (XO), who was aboard ship, giving the order to lower the national ensign (US flag). The XO then relayed the order to the crew member stationed at the bow of the ship who slowly lowered the flag. While the officers and crew saluted, the sailor marched off the ship.

Next came the order from the CO to the XO for the hauling down of the commissioning pennant (flown from the masthead), and again the order was called from the XO to the sailor. The sailor lowered the pennant and slowly marched off. This all took place in complete silence and as tears streamed down my face I saw that many others were emotional as well.

The last command was given by the CO to, "Secure the watch." At that moment, the continuous cycle of watch-standing ended, and Crommelin was no longer in commission.


John G. Crommelin V, flanked by the
USS Crommelin's first and last commanding officers,
Lanai Tea House, Pearl Harbor

Finally, after the traditional departure of the official party, the somber but deeply impressive decommissioning ceremony was over. It was a fitting tribute in an appropriate setting, to a ship that served the United States Navy faithfully for nearly 30 years and to the five Crommelin brothers whose valor and exceptional bravery left an indelible mark on US history.


Elizabeth Crommelin Pennewill and Elizabeth Bunce-Crommelin
at the reception following the ceremony

Katharine Crommelin Milton, PhD, is the daughter of John G. Crommelin, III, and lives in California

For more information on the USS Crommelin visit:
Link 1
Link 2
Link 3


The Famous Crommelin Brothers

Vice Admiral Henry Crommelin, whose eyesight prevented him from becoming a naval aviator instead became a Surface Warfare Officer. During WWII he commanded the destroyers USS Fitch (DD-462) which escorted Atlantic convoys and took part in the invasion of North Africa. In November 1943 he commanded Destroyer Division 50 from the bridge of the destroyer USS Ringgold (DD-500) during the Gilbert Islands Campaign for which he was awarded the Silver Star Medal for his gallantry. His citation read in part: “Commander Crommelin entered the perilous and uncharted waters of Tarawa lagoon in the first assault wave to this important Japanese stronghold. Operating in the treacherous, coral-studded lagoon, he valiantly directed his command in the vigorous bombardment of shore installations and contributed to the success of his division in silencing several enemy batteries.” He earned seven other medals and awards including the Bronze Star for heroism as commander of the same squadron during the amphibious assault which resulted in the capture and occupation of Guam, Mariana Islands. He commanded the heavy cruiser USS Des Moines (CA-134) during her service as flagship of the Sixth Fleet, and was Commander Battleship Division 2. Admiral Crommelin later served as Assistant Chief of Naval Personnel and Chief of Staff to Commander Destroyers, U.S. Atlantic Fleet. He served as Commander of the Naval Station Newport, Rhode Island, until his retirement in November 1959.

Commander Charles L. Crommelin, who flew the Hellcat (Grumman F6F), was awarded a Distinguished Flying Cross for action as Commander of a Fighting Squadron in an attack on Marcus Island on 31 August 1943. The following November he was awarded a gold star in lieu of a second Distinguished Flying Cross for action as Commander of Air Group Five during the Gilbert Islands Campaign. The citation read in part: “While leading an important reconnaissance flight over Mille Atoll on 21 November…in complete disregard for his personal safety and in the presence of determined anti-aircraft fire, he strafed one plane and was maneuvering to attack the other plane when his plane was struck by a shell which exploded within the cockpit, shattering the instruments and severely wounding him. With no vision in his left eye, his right wrist broken, a sever wound in his right chest, as well as many cuts and abrasions on his face, arms and body, and with forward visibility through the cockpit enclosure almost zero, despite loss of blood, he brought his plane back over one hundred miles and made a perfect landing aboard his carrier…” After assuming command of Carrier Air Group 12 he was awarded the Navy Cross for extraordinary heroism during the first carrier force raids on Japan in February 1945. On 28 March 1945 Commander Crommelin volunteered to fly from another aircraft carrier to participate in pre-invasion strikes on Okinawa. He never returned from that mission.

Lieutenant Commander Richard G. Crommelin graduated from the Naval Academy in 1938 and was assigned to the battleship USS Pennsylvania (BB-38). He later served in the Pacific as a Wildcat (Grumman F4F) aviator aboard the first carrier to bear the name USS Yorktown (CV-5). Flying off the Yorktown he took part in the early raids on the New Guinea ports of Lae and Salamaua and shot down two Japanese Zeros during the Battles of the Coral Sea, for which he received the Navy Cross for extraordinary heroism. His citation read in part: “…for extraordinary heroism in operations against the enemy… Crommelin conducted a determined and decisive attack against an enemy Japanese four-engine patrol plane which resulted in the destruction of that plane, thereby preventing the detection of our forces by the enemy. His aggressive spirit of fearlessness in facing great odds to make eight successive attacks against six enemy fighters attacking our surface forces and harassing our anti-Torpedo Plane patrol resulted in the destruction of two enemy fighters and severe damage to several others. His conduct in these engagements was characterized by unusual leadership, prompt and sound judgment in the accomplishment of his mission and a complete disregard for his own personal safety.” A month later, in the Battle of Midway, he earned a Gold Star in lieu of a second Navy Cross for his disruption of an eighteen-plane enemy attack. He was put in command of Fighting Squadron 88 in August 1944. His brilliant career continued until May 1945, when two months after the death of his brother Charles, he was killed in action when his plane collided over Japan with another plane in his squadron in heavy fog.

Rear Admiral John G. Crommelin, III, nicknamed "bomb-run John", earned a reputation as a courageous and skillful naval aviator. He served as executive officer as well as air officer aboard the most decorated ship in naval history, the aircraft carrier USS Enterprise (CV-6). Crommelin was acknowledged by the crew as the "heart and soul of the ‘Big-E’”. He was awarded the Legion of Merit with a Gold Star, a Combat "V", a Presidential Unit Citation, a Letter of Commendation, and a Purple Heart. He was chief of staff aboard the carrier USS Liscombe Bay (CVE-56) when it was sunk by a torpedo in the Makin Island Campaign off the Gilbert Islands. Of her crew of 916, Crommelin was one of only 272 who managed to reach the deck after the initial torpedo impact and survive. In 1946, Captain Crommelin was given command of America's newest and most modern aircraft carrier of the time, the USS Saipan (CVL-48). After the war he challenged Congress by arguing against the "Unification Act" which sought to eliminate the Navy's aircraft carrier force. His actions initiated what became known as "The Revolt of the Admirals," which resulted in the saving of the Navy's air arm, but cut short Crommelin's career as an admiral.

Captain Quentin C. Crommelin, the youngest of the five brothers, graduated from the Naval Academy in 1941. Before receiving his flight school orders he survived two torpedo attacks from Japanese submarines while aboard the aircraft carrier USS Saratoga (CV-3). In a 1988 oral history interview he said, “That was a very happy, pleasant time, that year before the war. I was out there when the war broke out. We were just going into the port at San Diego when we got the news that the war had started. We really didn't believe it. Then we sailed to Honolulu--to Pearl Harbor--and got there a few days after the attack. It was really something. I know many people have told you about it, probably a lot of them were there at the time. Coming into the port we passed by the ARIZONA, which was awash, and it was one of the most moving experiences I ever had. Her deck was sticking above water on the side of the channel going into Pearl there. We gave passing honors: On the ships everybody came to attention, sound attention, and hand-saluted and so forth. The survivors on deck of the ARIZONA also gave us passing honors. It was as quiet as could be. Seeing that ship sitting on the bottom with just its few survivors standing and saluting us as we went by, somehow got to me. It was a shambles when we got into the port. There was oil about two inches thick on the water. There was an occasional body that people in small boats would pick up and bring alongside. At night we would take a bunch of men and rifles and go out and man the beach. There would be a sailor about every hundred yards with an old World War I rifle to repel invasion…” After receiving his wings Quentin flew the Hellcat and the Vought F4U Corsair. The war ended as his squadron of fighter-bombers embarked on the aircraft carrier USS Antietam (CV-36). He was promoted to Captain in 1958. After the war he enjoyed a long career in the Navy commanding Air Group 17 and the aircraft carrier USS Lexington (CV-16). After leaving the Navy in 1973 he retired to his farm in Alabama.





Goodbye, USS Crommelin

...gone but not forgotten!